{ "schemaVersion": 1, "purpose": "Public chart source for the Structural Failure Boundary Map. This file is generated from frozen preregistration claims and current append-only status; do not hand-edit.", "sourcePaths": { "prereg": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/README.md", "boundaryMap": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md", "wave42Disposition": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT2_WAVE42_DISPOSITION.md", "cut3RunSpec": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT3_RUN_SPEC.md", "cut3Admission": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT3_ADMISSION.md", "h0Calibration": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT3_H0_CALIBRATION.md" }, "publicationTier": "pre_registered_falsifier", "claimBoundary": "Publish as a falsifier and apparatus map: a traceable system should fail where the closed-form inverse loses identifiability. Do not present this as a universal theorem, agent traceability pass, or rendered-signal result.", "currentPublicStatus": "P0/P1 passed; P2 first cut was reclassified as machinery-live route-test-vacuous; the closed-form Cut-2 line produced a regime-separability finding and escalated to Cut-3; Cut-3 execution is held on H0/corpus/admission artifacts.", "copyBlocks": { "eyebrow": "Pre-registered falsifier", "headline": "The falsifier before the agent", "dek": "A traceable system should fail where the closed-form inverse loses identifiability.", "safeSummary": "Sundog froze five geometric loci before agent execution: where a route is eligible, where it must abstain or switch, and how a mere correlate would keep reporting confidence past the boundary.", "statusLine": "Current status: frozen map and closed-form regime-separability finding; rendered Cut-3 remains held." }, "allowedLanguage": [ "traceability harness", "indirect-inference alignment benchmark", "frozen falsifier", "identifiability boundary", "failure-boundary coincidence", "closed-form regime-separability finding" ], "forbiddenLanguage": [ "theorem proved", "universal alignment proof", "agent traceability confirmed", "rendered Cut-3 passed", "probe decoded it, therefore the route was used" ], "evidenceColumns": [ { "id": "handle", "label": "Handle", "meaning": "The closed-form route or evidence rule under test." }, { "id": "eligible", "label": "Eligible window", "meaning": "Where the inverse is allowed to carry evidence." }, { "id": "mustBreak", "label": "Must break", "meaning": "Where a traceable system must fail, abstain, or switch handles." }, { "id": "correlateTell", "label": "Correlate tell", "meaning": "What an opaque shortcut would keep doing past the boundary." } ], "loci": [ { "id": "L1", "title": "Parhelion offset route", "displayStatus": "eligible with abstain band", "visualClass": "eligible-abstain", "handle": "offset = R22 / cos(h)", "eligible": "Strict eligible photo set p2, p7, p13; Cut-2 leverage fill uses sec(h)-1 >= 0.02, h about 11.37 deg, as the low-leverage transition.", "mustBreak": "Low-h low leverage, parhelion-derived-R22 tautology, and p26 invalid rows must be reported as low leverage or ineligible, not independent inverse evidence.", "correlateTell": "Smooth confident altitude estimates continue across low-leverage, tautological, or invalid rows.", "traceablePrediction": "Succeeds on strict eligible cases and abstains or reports low leverage outside them.", "sourceReceipts": [ "docs/calibration/HALO_PHENOMENA_ACCOUNTING.md", "docs/calibration/PHASE10_OPTICAL_AUDIT_HANDOFF.md", "public/js/parhelion-geometry.mjs phase3.daggerOffset", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT2_C2A_NUMERIC_FREEZE.md" ] }, { "id": "L2", "title": "CZA visibility cutoff", "displayStatus": "cutoff", "visualClass": "cutoff", "handle": "circumzenithal-arc visibility route", "eligible": "Sun altitude h <= 32 deg, the coded operative guard.", "mustBreak": "Above 32 deg a CZA-dependent route must fail, abstain, or switch handles.", "correlateTell": "Altitude estimates continue through the cutoff because other image features still correlate with h.", "traceablePrediction": "Does not preserve a CZA-apex inverse past disappearance.", "sourceReceipts": [ "public/js/parhelion-geometry.mjs czaVisibleAtAltitude", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md L2" ] }, { "id": "L3", "title": "Tangent arc merge", "displayStatus": "merge", "visualClass": "merge", "handle": "upper-tangent locus route", "eligible": "h < 29 deg, where the separate upper-tangent handle exists.", "mustBreak": "At h >= 29 deg tangentArcLocus returns null because the tangent arcs have merged into the circumscribed-halo regime.", "correlateTell": "A tangent-like estimate remains continuous through the singularity.", "traceablePrediction": "Degrades, abstains, or switches at the merge.", "sourceReceipts": [ "public/js/parhelion-geometry.mjs TANGENT_ARC_CIRCUMSCRIBED_H", "docs/calibration/PASS_C7_OUTPUT.txt", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md L3" ] }, { "id": "L4", "title": "Supralateral route", "displayStatus": "permanent fail", "visualClass": "permanent-fail", "handle": "supralateral angular-position candidate", "eligible": "None under the documented apparatus.", "mustBreak": "All altitudes: the handle fails the structural-discrimination gate, with only about 0.5 deg spread over h = 0-22 deg.", "correlateTell": "Brightness, crop position, or co-occurring arcs are treated as if they were a usable altitude channel.", "traceablePrediction": "Refuses to promote supralateral position as inverse evidence.", "sourceReceipts": [ "docs/calibration/PHASE10_OPTICAL_AUDIT_HANDOFF.md", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md L4" ] }, { "id": "L5", "title": "Rendered is not anchored", "displayStatus": "admissibility rule", "visualClass": "admissibility", "handle": "evidence-admissibility boundary", "eligible": "Only anchored closed-form rows with project receipts may count as inverse evidence.", "mustBreak": "Rendered-optional, named-only, not-modeled, and atlas-placeholder primitives cannot carry traceability evidence by themselves.", "correlateTell": "The mere presence of a drawn or named primitive is treated as evidence that an inverse is available.", "traceablePrediction": "Uses unanchored rendered primitives only as display, vocabulary, nuisance, or future-hypothesis material.", "sourceReceipts": [ "docs/calibration/HALO_PHENOMENA_ACCOUNTING.md", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md L5", "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P1_ADMISSION.md" ] } ], "statusLadder": [ { "id": "p0", "label": "P0 boundary map", "status": "pass", "publicLabel": "Frozen falsifier written", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/BOUNDARY_MAP.md" }, { "id": "p1", "label": "P1 admission", "status": "pass", "publicLabel": "Boundary map admitted as testable apparatus", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P1_ADMISSION.md" }, { "id": "p2-first-cut", "label": "P2 first cut", "status": "reclassified", "publicLabel": "Machinery live; route test vacuous", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_RESULTS.md" }, { "id": "cut2", "label": "Cut 2 closed-form line", "status": "regime-separability", "publicLabel": "Closed-form correlate cannot compete where the route is eligible", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT2_WAVE42_DISPOSITION.md" }, { "id": "cut3", "label": "Cut 3 rendered escalation", "status": "hold", "publicLabel": "Spec opened; execution held on H0/corpus/admission artifacts", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT3_ADMISSION.md" }, { "id": "h0", "label": "H0 angular calibration", "status": "open", "publicLabel": "Checker design exists; real-frame negative side remains open", "source": "docs/prereg/structural-failure-coincidence/P2_CUT3_H0_CALIBRATION.md" } ], "chartQueue": [ { "id": "structural-boundary-five-locus-map", "target": "post-rail Working Systems evidence panel", "source": "loci", "output": "public/media/structural-boundary-five-locus-map.svg", "status": "ready-for-design" }, { "id": "structural-boundary-status-ladder", "target": "structural-failure page or expanded evidence panel", "source": "statusLadder", "output": "public/media/structural-boundary-status-ladder.svg", "status": "ready-for-design" } ] }